{"status":"OK","data":{"id":662771,"identifier":"VSGHGA","persistentUrl":"https://doi.org/10.34894/VSGHGA","protocol":"doi","authority":"10.34894","separator":"/","publisher":"DataverseNL","publicationDate":"2026-09-21","storageIdentifier":"surf://10.34894/VSGHGA","effectiveDatasetFileCountLimit":10000,"datasetFileUploadsAvailable":9999,"datasetType":"dataset","locks":[],"latestVersion":{"id":35190,"datasetId":662771,"datasetPersistentId":"doi:10.34894/VSGHGA","datasetType":"dataset","storageIdentifier":"surf://10.34894/VSGHGA","versionNumber":1,"internalVersionNumber":51,"versionMinorNumber":0,"versionState":"RELEASED","latestVersionPublishingState":"RELEASED","lastUpdateTime":"2026-09-21T10:45:59Z","releaseTime":"2026-09-21T10:45:59Z","createTime":"2026-08-17T10:34:35Z","publicationDate":"2026-09-21","citationDate":"2026-09-21","effectiveDatasetFileCountLimit":10000,"datasetFileUploadsAvailable":9999,"license":{"name":"CC0-1.0","uri":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0","iconUri":"https://licensebuttons.net/p/zero/1.0/88x31.png","rightsIdentifier":"CC0-1.0","rightsIdentifierScheme":"SPDX","schemeUri":"https://spdx.org/licenses/","languageCode":"en"},"fileAccessRequest":false,"metadataBlocks":{"citation":{"displayName":"Citation Metadata","name":"citation","fields":[{"typeName":"title","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Plurality in transformative change: three co-created pathways toward nature-positive Europe(s) – Replication Data"},{"typeName":"author","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"authorName":{"typeName":"authorName","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"de Pater, Mara"},"authorAffiliation":{"typeName":"authorAffiliation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Dutch Research Institute for Transitions, Erasmus University Rotterdam"},"authorIdentifierScheme":{"typeName":"authorIdentifierScheme","multiple":false,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":"ORCID"},"authorIdentifier":{"typeName":"authorIdentifier","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"0000-0001-9414-6200"}},{"authorName":{"typeName":"authorName","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Hebinck, Aniek"},"authorAffiliation":{"typeName":"authorAffiliation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Dutch Research Institute for Transitions, Erasmus University Rotterdam"},"authorIdentifierScheme":{"typeName":"authorIdentifierScheme","multiple":false,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":"ORCID"},"authorIdentifier":{"typeName":"authorIdentifier","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"0000-0002-6441-374X"}},{"authorName":{"typeName":"authorName","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Teunissen, Aron"},"authorAffiliation":{"typeName":"authorAffiliation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Natuur & Milieu"}},{"authorName":{"typeName":"authorName","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Nieboer, Symke"},"authorAffiliation":{"typeName":"authorAffiliation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Dutch Research Institute for Transitions, Erasmus University Rotterdam"},"authorIdentifierScheme":{"typeName":"authorIdentifierScheme","multiple":false,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":"ORCID"},"authorIdentifier":{"typeName":"authorIdentifier","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"0009-0004-0828-3073"}}]},{"typeName":"datasetContact","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"datasetContactName":{"typeName":"datasetContactName","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"de Pater, Mara"},"datasetContactAffiliation":{"typeName":"datasetContactAffiliation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Dutch Research Institute for Transitions, Erasmus University Rotterdam"}}]},{"typeName":"dsDescription","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"dsDescriptionValue":{"typeName":"dsDescriptionValue","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"<h3>Dataset Description</h3> \nThis dataset contains materials generated during the second workshop of an iterative co-creation process focused on developing transformative pathways. The workshop formed part of a structured participatory research design in which stakeholders collaboratively developed, refined, and evaluated pathways for systemic change. The materials archived here represent the digitized and structured outputs of the second workshop. These outputs were subsequently analysed by the research team and serve as the empirical basis for further pathway development and scholarly analysis.\n\n<h3>Background</h3> \nEurope is experiencing rapid biodiversity loss, requiring transformative change rather than incremental policy adjustments. However, there is no single understanding of what transformative change means or how a nature-positive future should be achieved. This study explores different possible pathways toward a nature-positive Europe.\n\n<h3>Purpose</h3> \nTo explore different pathways toward a nature-positive Europe and how different understandings of transformative change shape these pathways.\n\n<h3>Data Collection and Methods</h3> \n<i>● Data Processing and anonymization milestones </i><br>\nAll materials have been digitized and, where necessary, anonymized to remove identifiable personal information. The dataset reflects the outputs as generated during the co-creation process, with minimal transformation beyond structuring and formatting for analytical clarity. <br><br>\n\nThe materials archived here represent the digitized and structured outputs of the second workshop. These outputs were subsequently analysed by the research team and serve as the empirical basis for further pathway development and scholarly analysis.\n\n\n<h3>Research Limitations</h3> \nThe co-creation methodology shaped the pathways that emerged, with participants tending to converge around dominant perspectives within their groups, thereby limiting the diversity of views within each pathway. The study involved only 23 participants, with follow-up interviews with 9 participants, which limits the range of perspectives represented. Consequently, the findings provide valuable qualitative insights into possible pathways toward a nature-positive Europe but are not intended to be representative of all European stakeholders or predictive of future developments.\n\n<h3>Data Structure and Relationships Between Files</h3> \n\nThe dataset includes: <br><br>\n\n<i>● Digitized raw workshop data </i><br>\nTranscribed and anonymized outputs produced by participants during Workshop 2 (e.g.,\nflipcharts, templates, written inputs). <br><br>\n\n<i>● Structured tables of actions and milestones </i><br>\nResearcher-organized tables capturing proposed actions, sequencing, milestones, and\npathway elements derived from workshop materials. <br><br>\n\n<i>● Summarized discussion notes </i><br>\nSynthesized notes documenting key discussions, reflections, and deliberations during\nthe workshop. <br><br>\n\n<i>● Synthesis of webinar outcomes </i><br>\nA structured summary of insights from a follow-up webinar in which pathway elements\nwere discussed and refined. <br><br>\n\n<h3>Value of the data for potential reuse</h3> \nThis dataset supports the findings reported in the associated journal <a href=\"https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.70418\">article</a>. It enables transparency regarding the structure of the co-created pathways and the analytical steps undertaken in interpreting workshop outputs. \n\n<h3>Results</h3> \nThree distinct pathways emerged, each reflecting a different approach to transformative change: Dòigh Nàdair emphasises community-led action and biocultural values; NaturAll focuses on sufficiency, ecological limits, and stronger regulation; and Return to Nature highlights institutional action, expert knowledge, and innovation.\n\n<h3>Conclusion</h3>\nThere is no single pathway to a nature-positive Europe; different perspectives can lead to diverse but complementary pathways."}}]},{"typeName":"subject","multiple":true,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":["Social Sciences"]},{"typeName":"keyword","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"keywordValue":{"typeName":"keywordValue","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"co-created pathways"}}]},{"typeName":"publication","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"publicationRelationType":{"typeName":"publicationRelationType","multiple":false,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":"IsSupplementTo"},"publicationCitation":{"typeName":"publicationCitation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"de Pater, M., Hebinck, A., Nieboer, S., Lazurko, A., Biesbroek, R., Pereira, L., Díaz-General, E., Teunissen, A., Baadj, S., Chilton, A., Krupnik, S., Kock, R., Näkkäläjärvi, K., Rozemuller, W. M., & Sakellari, E. (2026). Plurality in transformative change: Three co-created pathways toward nature-positive Europe(s). People and Nature."},"publicationIDType":{"typeName":"publicationIDType","multiple":false,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":"doi"},"publicationIDNumber":{"typeName":"publicationIDNumber","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"10.1002/pan3.70418"},"publicationURL":{"typeName":"publicationURL","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.70418"}}]},{"typeName":"notesText","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"<p>This entry is a four-files data package totaling 2.08 MB when uncompressed, containing files in .pdf, .txt and .zip formats.</p> <p>If you use this dataset, please cite: <p>de Pater, M., Hebinck, A., Teunissen, A., & Nieboer, S. (2026). <i> Plurality in transformative change: Three co-created pathways toward nature-positive europe(s) – replication data </i> (Version V1) [Dataset]. DataverseNL. <a href=\"https://doi.org/10.34894/VSGHGA\" target=\"https://doi.org/10.34894/VSGHGA\"> https://doi.org/10.34894/VSGHGA </a></p></p>"},{"typeName":"language","multiple":true,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":["English"]},{"typeName":"producer","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"producerName":{"typeName":"producerName","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"BIONEXT"},"producerURL":{"typeName":"producerURL","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"https://www.bionext-project.eu/"}}]},{"typeName":"depositor","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"de Pater, Mara"},{"typeName":"dateOfDeposit","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"2026-07-14"},{"typeName":"dateOfCollection","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"dateOfCollectionStart":{"typeName":"dateOfCollectionStart","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"2026-05-01"},"dateOfCollectionEnd":{"typeName":"dateOfCollectionEnd","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"2026-11-30"}}]},{"typeName":"kindOfData","multiple":true,"typeClass":"primitive","value":["Qualitative social-environmental"]}]},"geospatial":{"displayName":"Geospatial Metadata","name":"geospatial","fields":[{"typeName":"geographicCoverage","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"otherGeographicCoverage":{"typeName":"otherGeographicCoverage","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Europe"}}]}]},"socialscience":{"displayName":"Social Science and Humanities Metadata","name":"socialscience","fields":[{"typeName":"unitOfAnalysis","multiple":true,"typeClass":"primitive","value":["The three co-created pathways: Dòigh Nàdair, NaturAll, and Return to Nature."]},{"typeName":"universe","multiple":true,"typeClass":"primitive","value":["Diverse European stakeholders (N=23) involved in or concerned with transformative change toward a nature-positive Europe"]},{"typeName":"targetSampleSize","multiple":false,"typeClass":"compound","value":{"targetSampleActualSize":{"typeName":"targetSampleActualSize","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"23"}}},{"typeName":"dataCollectionSituation","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"Co-creation workshops were used"}]},"journal":{"displayName":"Journal Metadata","name":"journal","fields":[{"typeName":"journalVolumeIssue","multiple":true,"typeClass":"compound","value":[{"journalPubDate":{"typeName":"journalPubDate","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"2026-09"}}]},{"typeName":"journalArticleType","multiple":false,"typeClass":"controlledVocabulary","value":"research article"}]},"dansDataVaultMetadata":{"displayName":"Data Vault Metadata","name":"dansDataVaultMetadata","fields":[{"typeName":"dansDataversePid","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"doi:10.34894/VSGHGA"},{"typeName":"dansDataversePidVersion","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"1.0"},{"typeName":"dansBagId","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"urn:uuid:4e12f2f9-36b6-4e9c-aaf0-08696a04d335"},{"typeName":"dansNbn","multiple":false,"typeClass":"primitive","value":"urn:nbn:nl:ui:13-35b14282-5760-4c43-ae95-07e14b5cef01"}]}},"files":[{"description":"","label":"doi-10.34894-vsghga_data-package_2026.zip","restricted":false,"version":1,"datasetVersionId":35190,"dataFile":{"id":673728,"persistentId":"","filename":"doi-10.34894-vsghga_data-package_2026.zip","contentType":"application/zip","friendlyType":"ZIP Archive","filesize":879476,"description":"","storageIdentifier":"surf://store:1a09147fce1-32e8106c7ce8","rootDataFileId":-1,"checksum":{"type":"SHA-1","value":"427bb8cbc70acb728d2609c7904b2bf95e487e18"},"tabularData":false,"creationDate":"2026-09-11","publicationDate":"2026-09-21","lastUpdateTime":"2026-09-21T10:45:59Z","fileAccessRequest":false}}]}}}